Four steps to complete an experimental research design

Experimental research designs are one of the classic approaches to empirical research—gathering research data in a way that is verifiable by observation or experience. But what exactly is an experimental research design, and how can you use one in your own research? In this in-depth guide, we’ll give you an overview of experimental research, describe the different types of experimental design, discuss the advantages and disadvantages of this approach and walk you through the four steps for completing experimental research.

Experimental research is scientifically-driven, quantitative research involving two sets of variables. The first set of variables, known as the independent variables, are manipulated by the researcher, in order to determine the impact on the second set of variables—the dependent variables. Using the experimental method, you can test whether, and how, the independent variables impact the dependent variable, which can help support a wide range of decisions in areas such as:

These are just a few different areas of consumer research that are suitable for experimental research. However, not all experimental research designs are equivalent. Let's take a look at the three different types of experimental design you might consider using, and some of the types of research questions they could be used for.

The simplest type of experimental design is called a pre-experimental research design, and it has many different manifestations. Using a pre-experiment, some factor or treatment that is expected to cause change is implemented for a group or multiple groups of research subjects, and the subjects are observed over a period of time. 

Different types of pre-experimental research design include:

In this type of design, some type of treatment is applied to a single case study sample group. The group is then studied to determine whether the implementation of the treatment caused change, by comparing observations to general expectations of what the case would have looked like had the treatment not been implemented. There is no control or comparison group.

This type of design also involves observing one group with no control or comparison group.  However, the group is observed at two points in time: once before the intervention is applied and once after the intervention is applied. For instance, if you want to determine whether concentration increases in a group of students after they  take part in a study skills course, you might employ this type of experimental design. Any observed changes in the dependent variable are assumed to be the consequence of the intervention or treatment. 

This type of design compares two groups. One that has experienced some intervention or treatment and one that has not. If any differences are observed between the two groups, it is presumed to be because of the treatment.

A true experimental research design involves testing a hypothesis in order to determine whether there is a cause-effect relationship between two or more sets of variables. Although there are a few established ways to conduct experimental research designs, all share four characteristics: 

This type of approach might be used in concept testing, such as comparing the impact of changes of packaging design among a treatment group and a group that receives the original packaging. 

Finally, a quasi-experimental research design follows some of the same principles as the true experimental design, but the research subjects are not randomly assigned to the control or treatment group. This type of research design often occurs in natural settings, where it is not possible for the researcher to control the assignment of subjects. An example of a  quasi-experimental research design is a researcher presenting Saturday shoppers at a grocery store with a welcome banner and comparing their perceptions of how welcoming the store was to those visiting the store on a Tuesday when the banner was not present.

Now that you know what kinds of experimental designs are available, let’s focus on the steps you should take to set up your design. 

In the first stage, establish your research question, and use it to distinguish between dependent and independent variables.

Independent vs. dependent variables

Independent variables are the variables that will be subjected to some kind of manipulation, and which are expected to impact the outcome. In contrast, the dependent variables are not manipulated, but represent the outcome and are expected to be impacted by the independent variables.  For instance, if you are performing ad testing, you might have a research question like this: